Home News Cyclist positive outcomes rise for the first time in five quarters

Cyclist positive outcomes rise for the first time in five quarters

402
0

Operation Snap Quarter 1 2024: The decline reverses

Between January and March 2024, West Yorkshire Police processed 2,001 submissions through Operation Snap. Cyclist submissions totalled 757. Both figures are significantly higher than the same period a year earlier — Quarter 1 2023 recorded 1,546 submissions, of which 526 came from cyclists. The system is handling more footage than it was 12 months ago.

The cyclist positive outcome rate was 75.4%. After four consecutive quarters of decline — from 81.9% in Quarter 1 2023 to 72.6% in Quarter 4 2023 — the rate rose for the first time. The increase is 2.8 percentage points on the previous quarter. Whether this marks the start of a recovery or a single-quarter fluctuation is not something one data point can answer, but the direction changed.

Year on year, the picture is mixed. The cyclist positive outcome rate fell 6.5 percentage points from Quarter 1 2023’s 81.9%. The vehicle driver rate fell 5.7 percentage points, from 68.3% to 62.6%. Vehicle passengers fell furthest — from 73.8% to 49.3%, a drop of 24.5 percentage points. Fewer than half of vehicle passenger submissions now produce a positive outcome.

Pedestrians and horse riders moved in the opposite direction. Pedestrian positive outcomes rose from 40.5% in Quarter 1 2023 to 53.9%, continuing the improvement that began in Quarter 2 2023. Horse riders recorded 87.8% — 43 positive outcomes from 49 submissions. In Quarter 4 2023, horse riders recorded 41.9%. The swing across a single quarter is 45.9 percentage points. This is the highest horse rider positive outcome rate in the dataset.

The offence mix in cyclist submissions shifted in a way that has implications for the rest of the data. Phone use (RV86019) is now the second most common offence code in cyclist submissions at 11.2% of identified offences, overtaking RT88575 — due care and attention — which dropped to 8.9%. In Quarter 1 2023, phone use accounted for 3.9% and RT88575 for 16.7%. The system categorised a larger share of cyclist-reported driving as phone use and a smaller share as due care. RT88576 — reasonable consideration — remained the dominant code at 72.0%, down from 75.2% in Quarter 1 2023.

That shift affects the outcome profile. Phone use produces a near-automatic conditional offer — 97 of 99 phone submissions across all reporter types resulted in a conditional offer in this quarter. A higher proportion of phone use in cyclist submissions means a higher proportion of conditional offers, which are a more serious outcome than the educational courses that RT88576 almost always produces. The system is categorising more cyclist-reported driving under a code that carries a fixed penalty.

Where the system categorised cyclist-reported driving as RT88576, the educational course rate was 98.3% — 404 of 411. Seven resulted in conditional offers. None went to court. RT88576 continues to produce court outcomes only rarely — two cases in Quarter 3 2023, none in any other quarter.

RT88575 produced a broader range of outcomes from cyclist submissions — 82.4% educational courses, 15.7% conditional offers, and one court prosecution (2.0%) in Bradford in January. Across all reporter types, 13 of the 14 court cases in this quarter carried the code RT88575. The remaining one was for RT88975 — failing to comply with traffic signals.

The district picture in Quarter 1 2024 shows Bradford handling by far the largest volume of cyclist submissions — 257, more than double any previous quarter. Bradford’s positive outcome rate was 75.9%, up from 74.5% in Quarter 4 2023 but still well below its Quarter 1 2023 figure of 90.4%.

Leeds recorded 77.3% from 295 cyclist submissions — up from 72.6% in Quarter 4 2023 and the first increase in five quarters. Kirklees recorded 74.7% from 91 submissions, almost identical to its Quarter 1 2023 figure of 74.5%. Calderdale recorded 77.1% from 48 submissions.

Wakefield continued to decline. The positive outcome rate for cyclist submissions was 70.5% from 61 submissions — the lowest of any district. In Quarter 1 2023, Wakefield recorded 93.3% from 30 submissions. The year-on-year decline is 22.8 percentage points. Wakefield’s no further action rate for cyclist submissions was 29.5% — nearly three in 10 submissions resulted in no further action.

Submission volumes grew across the quarter — 476 in January, 711 in February, 814 in March. Cyclist submissions followed the same pattern — 171, 278, 308. March recorded the highest monthly volume, reversing the decline that ran through Quarter 4 2023.

For the fifth consecutive quarter, no cyclist was dealt with through their own footage. Of 757 cyclist submissions, not one record shows the system acting against the cyclist who submitted it.

Data source: West Yorkshire Police Operation Snap, January–March 2024. Analysis by West Yorkshire Cycling.