
Between July and September 2023, West Yorkshire Police processed 2,276 submissions through Operation Snap — down from 2,427 in Quarter 2 and the first quarter-on-quarter decline of the year. Cyclist submissions fell slightly from 875 to 844. The overall positive outcome rate dropped for the third consecutive quarter, from 71.3% in Quarter 1 to 70.5% in Quarter 2 to 67.4% in Quarter 3. The cyclist positive outcome rate followed the same trajectory — 81.9%, then 77.4%, then 73.6%. Three quarters into 2023, the direction is consistent. The question is what is driving it.
The court figures changed. In Quarter 2, the system sent 21 cases to court and not one came from a cyclist submission. In Quarter 3, the system again sent 21 cases to court — and five came from cyclist submissions. Three of those five were for RT88575 — driving without due care and attention — which has produced court outcomes in every quarter this year. But two were for RT88576 — driving without reasonable consideration to others. In Quarter 1 and Quarter 2 combined, 863 cyclist submissions carried the code RT88576. None went to court. In Quarter 3, two did — one in Kirklees in July, one in Leeds in August. These are the first RT88576 court outcomes from cyclist submissions in the dataset. The previous two quarters established that the system treated RT88576 as an educational matter almost without exception. Quarter 3 shows exceptions exist.
The remaining 16 court cases came from vehicle drivers and carried the code RT88575 in all but one instance — the exception being a traffic signal offence (RT88975) in Calderdale. RT88575 remains the dominant route to court, accounting for 18 of 21 prosecutions across all reporter types.
The district picture shifted again. Wakefield recorded the highest cyclist positive outcome rate in Quarter 1 at 93.3% and remained the strongest district in Quarter 2 at 85.9%. In Quarter 3 it recorded 71.4% from 63 submissions — the lowest of any district. The decline across three quarters is 21.9 percentage points. Wakefield’s no further action rate for cyclist submissions rose from 6.7% in Quarter 1 to 14.1% in Quarter 2 to 28.6% in Quarter 3. Nearly three in 10 cyclist submissions in Wakefield now result in no further action.
Bradford plateaued. The large drop from 90.4% in Quarter 1 to 76.4% in Quarter 2 did not continue — Quarter 3 recorded 75.0% from 148 submissions, with the no further action rate holding at 25.0% against Quarter 2’s 23.6%.
Kirklees reversed again. The district improved from 74.5% in Quarter 1 to 84.2% in Quarter 2. In Quarter 3 it dropped back to 74.6% from 118 submissions — almost exactly where it started. Leeds, which processed the largest volume in every quarter, recorded 74.8% from 453 submissions, continuing a steady decline from 80.6% in Quarter 1 and 75.2% in Quarter 2. Calderdale recorded 75.5% from 49 submissions, up from 71.1% in Quarter 2.
Over three quarters, no district has maintained a consistent trajectory. Wakefield declined sharply. Bradford fell and then levelled off. Kirklees improved and then fell back. Leeds declined steadily. Calderdale dropped and then recovered. The data record these movements but do not show whether they reflect changes in the footage submitted, changes in how officers assess it, or something else entirely.
Phone use through Operation Snap is no longer a guaranteed conditional offer. In Quarter 2, every one of the 82 submissions for using a handheld phone resulted in a conditional offer. In Quarter 3, 61 of 65 did. Four resulted in educational courses — all four from cyclist submissions in Leeds in September. The same district, the same month, the same reporter type. In three quarters, phone use has gone from 41 of 42 conditional offers in Quarter 1, to 82 of 82 in Quarter 2, to 61 of 65 in Quarter 3.
The offence code hierarchy identified in Quarter 1 is loosening. RT88576 still produces educational courses in 97.1% of cyclist submissions — identical to Quarter 2 — but it now produces court outcomes, which it did not in the first two quarters. RT88575 produced educational courses in 85.2% of cyclist submissions, conditional offers in 9.8%, and court outcomes in 4.9% — a higher court rate than any previous quarter. Phone use, previously an automatic conditional offer, now produces educational courses in specific circumstances.
The positive outcome rate fell for every reporter type except vehicle passengers, who recorded 57.0% against 55.1% in Quarter 2. Cyclists fell from 77.4% to 73.6%. Vehicle drivers fell from 67.6% to 66.3%. Pedestrians fell from 67.2% to 60.6%, though they remain well above their Quarter 1 figure of 40.5%. Horse riders recorded the sharpest drop — from 73.6% in Quarter 2 to 53.3% in Quarter 3. Only 24 of 45 horse rider submissions produced a positive outcome. None resulted in a conditional offer or court prosecution — every positive outcome was an educational course.
For the third consecutive quarter, no cyclist was dealt with through their own footage. Of 844 cyclist submissions, not one record shows the system acting against the cyclist who submitted it.
Three quarters of data now show a system in which the broad patterns hold but the detail shifts. The offence code still largely determines the disposal, but the boundaries are less rigid than they appeared in Quarter 1. The positive outcome rate for cyclist submissions is declining, and the decline is consistent across quarters. The district variation remains large and unpredictable. These are the patterns the data establish. Whether they represent a system settling into a pattern after Quarter 1’s higher rates or a system producing fewer outcomes as volumes grow is something the data cannot yet answer.
Data source: West Yorkshire Police Operation Snap, July–September 2023. Analysis by West Yorkshire Cycling.


























