Home News Operation Snap received 875 cyclist submissions in Q2 2023 and sent none...

Operation Snap received 875 cyclist submissions in Q2 2023 and sent none to court

388
0

Between April and June 2023, West Yorkshire Police processed 2,427 submissions through Operation Snap — a 57% increase on the 1,546 in Quarter 1. Cyclist submissions rose 66%, from 526 to 875. Pedestrian submissions more than tripled, from 79 to 256. The overall positive outcome rate barely moved — 70.5% against 71.3% in Quarter 1 — but underneath that stable headline, almost everything else shifted.

Of the 875 cyclist submissions in Quarter 2, not one resulted in a court prosecution. Zero. The system sent 21 cases to court during the quarter and every one came from a non-cyclist reporter — 17 from vehicle drivers, three from vehicle passengers, one from an unknown reporter type. In Quarter 1, two of the 20 court cases came from cyclist submissions. In Quarter 2, with 66% more cyclist submissions, the number dropped to none. Every court prosecution in Quarter 2 was for RT88575 — driving without due care and attention — the same pattern as Quarter 1, where 19 of 20 court cases carried that code. The system sends cases to court exclusively under the more serious offence code, and in Quarter 2 it did not apply that route to a single cyclist-reported case.

That sits alongside a broader decline in cyclist positive outcomes. The positive outcome rate for cyclist submissions fell from 81.9% in Quarter 1 to 77.4% in Quarter 2 — a 4.5-percentage-point drop. Cyclists remained the most effective reporter type in the dataset. Vehicle drivers recorded 67.6% (down from 68.3%). Horse riders recorded 73.6% (up from 65.5%). Pedestrians recorded 67.2% (up from 40.5%). Vehicle passengers recorded 55.1% (down from 73.8%). The cyclist and vehicle passenger figures fell. The pedestrian and horse rider figures rose. The vehicle driver figure barely moved. The overall rate held steady because the shifts in different directions largely cancelled each other out.

The pedestrian transformation is the most dramatic shift between the two quarters. In Quarter 1, 79 pedestrians submitted footage and the system identified an actionable offence in fewer than half of those cases. In Quarter 2, 256 pedestrians submitted footage and the positive outcome rate jumped to 67.2% — a 26.7-percentage-point increase. The offence mix tells the story. In Quarter 1, the most common identified offence in pedestrian submissions was RT88966 — failing to comply with a traffic sign. In Quarter 2, the system categorised pedestrian-reported driving as due care and attention (RT88575, 49 submissions), failing to comply with traffic signals (RT88975, 48), and using a handheld phone (RV86019, 26). Pedestrians in Quarter 2 submitted footage that produced serious offence codes and serious outcomes. The growth was concentrated in Leeds, which accounted for 186 of the 256 pedestrian submissions with a 75.3% positive outcome rate. Bradford recorded just 14 pedestrian submissions and only two produced a positive outcome.

The vehicle passenger figures moved in the opposite direction to pedestrians. In Quarter 1, vehicle passengers recorded a 73.8% positive outcome rate from 65 submissions — the second highest of any reporter type behind cyclists. In Quarter 2, the rate fell to 55.1% from 78 submissions. No further action rose from 26.2% of passenger submissions in Quarter 1 to 44.9% in Quarter 2. Nearly half of all vehicle passenger submissions in Quarter 2 resulted in no further action. Three vehicle passenger submissions went to court in Quarter 2 — the only reporter type other than vehicle drivers to produce court outcomes this quarter. In Quarter 1, no vehicle passenger submissions went to court.

The district figures for cyclist submissions shifted substantially between quarters. Bradford dropped from the highest positive outcome rate in Quarter 1 at 90.4% to 76.4% in Quarter 2 — a 14-percentage-point fall. Bradford’s no further action rate for cyclist submissions more than doubled, from 9.6% to 23.6%. Kirklees moved in the opposite direction, from the lowest positive outcome rate in Quarter 1 at 74.5% to 84.2% in Quarter 2 — a 9.7-percentage-point improvement, with the no further action rate dropping from 25.5% to 15.8%. The two districts swapped positions in a single quarter. Wakefield fell from 93.3% to 85.9% despite handling more than three times the volume — 99 submissions against 30. Leeds processed the largest share in both quarters and its positive outcome rate fell from 80.6% to 75.2%. The data do not explain why these shifts occurred. They could reflect changes in the footage submitted, changes in how officers assess it, or variation across a growing dataset. But the scale of the Bradford and Kirklees reversals — 14 percentage points down and 9.7 up — is difficult to attribute to random variation alone.

The offence code hierarchy identified in Quarter 1 held firm. When the system categorised cyclist-reported driving as RT88576 — reasonable consideration — the outcome was an educational course in 97.1% of cases, a conditional offer in 2.9%, and a court prosecution in none. In Quarter 1 the educational course rate for RT88576 was 98.5%. The shift is small but consistent — a slightly larger share of RT88576 cases resulted in conditional offers. When officers categorised driving under RT88575, the pattern of outcomes broadened — 87.1% educational course, 12.9% conditional offer for cyclist submissions. Across all reporters, every one of the 21 court prosecutions carried the code RT88575. RT88576 produced zero court outcomes for the second consecutive quarter.

Phone use through Operation Snap is now a guaranteed conditional offer. In Quarter 1, 41 of 42 submissions for using a handheld phone resulted in a conditional offer — one resulted in an educational course. In Quarter 2, 82 of 82 did. Every single submission, across all reporter types. There is no longer any variation in the outcome.

The proportion of cyclist-reported driving that the system categorised as RT88576 rose from 75.2% of identified offences in Quarter 1 to 80.5% in Quarter 2. RT88575 dropped from 16.7% to 10.3%. The system categorised a larger share of cyclist-reported driving under the less serious code — the one that carries an almost automatic educational course and never produces a court prosecution.

For the second consecutive quarter, no cyclist was dealt with through their own footage. Of 875 cyclist submissions, not one record shows the system acting against the cyclist who submitted it. The system was built around motor vehicles and continues to function that way.

Two quarters of data do not establish trends. But they do establish questions. Why did Bradford’s cyclist no further action rate more than double while Kirklees improved by nearly 10 percentage points? Why did the proportion of cyclist-reported driving categorised as RT88576 rise? Why did no cyclist submission reach court in a quarter in which the system prosecuted 21 other cases? The data record these patterns. They do not explain them. Future quarters will show whether they hold.

Data source: West Yorkshire Police Operation Snap, April–June 2023. Analysis by West Yorkshire Cycling.