
Operation Snap Q1 2023: What the West Yorkshire Police data actually show
Between January and March 2023, West Yorkshire Police processed 1,546 submissions through Operation Snap. West Yorkshire Cycling has analysed every record. The overall positive outcome rate was 71.3%, rising to 81.9% for the 526 cyclist submissions. But the more interesting findings lie beneath those figures, in the structure of how the system processes different types of offence, the contrast between cyclist and driver submissions, and the significant variation in outcomes across West Yorkshire’s five districts.
Start with what people report. Cyclists and vehicle drivers use Operation Snap to report fundamentally different things. Three-quarters of cyclist submissions with an identified offence were RT88576 — driving without reasonable consideration to others. A further 16.7% were RT88575 — driving without due care and attention — and 3.9% were RV86019, using a handheld phone while driving. Both RT88576 and RT88575 can cover the same types of driving behaviour, including close passes, but RT88575 is the more serious charge. The picture for vehicle drivers is entirely different. Their most common offence code was RT88575 at 41.0%, followed by RT88975 — failing to comply with traffic signals — at 21.9%, and RT88971 — failing to comply with a red light — at 9.1%. Drivers reported RT88576 just 4.0% of the time. Cyclists report how drivers behave around them. Drivers report how other drivers handle their vehicles and respond to road infrastructure. The two groups use the same system to report largely different categories of driving behaviour.
That distinction matters because the offence code is the single strongest predictor of what happens next. Of the 324 cyclist submissions coded RT88576, 319 resulted in an educational course. Five resulted in conditional offers. None went to court. That is a 98.5% educational course rate for the offence cyclists report most often. Across all reporter types, the pattern is identical — 98.1% of all RT88576 submissions resulted in a course. The system treats this offence code as an educational matter almost without exception.
RT88575 — due care and attention — produces an entirely different pattern of outcomes. Across all reporters, 71.3% of RT88575 submissions resulted in an educational course, 22.7% in a conditional offer, and 5.9% went to court. For cyclist submissions, 90.3% of RT88575 cases resulted in an educational course, 6.9% in a conditional offer, and 2.8% went to court. The offence code does most of the work in determining disposal.
This becomes particularly visible in the court figures. Of the 20 court prosecutions in Q1 2023, 19 were for RT88575. One was for RC86815 — driver not in position to have full view ahead. Not a single RT88576 submission went to court. Only two of those 20 court cases came from cyclist submissions — one in Calderdale in January, one in Leeds in March — and both were for RT88575. The data do not tell us what the driving behaviour was in those cases. A close pass serious enough to warrant an RT88575 charge rather than RT88576 can reach court. A close pass under RT88576 cannot — in this quarter, none did. The data show that disposal is not a case-by-case judgement on the severity of the driving. It is, overwhelmingly, a function of which offence code the system assigns.
Handheld phone use sits in its own category. Of the 42 submissions coded RV86019 across all reporter types, 41 resulted in a conditional offer — a fixed penalty with penalty points. Only one resulted in an educational course. Every single one of the 17 cyclist submissions for phone use resulted in a conditional offer. This is effectively a fixed-tariff outcome. Capture a driver on their phone and submit it through Operation Snap, and the result is, statistically, predetermined.
The district breakdown adds another layer. Cyclist positive outcome rates ranged from 93.3% in Wakefield to 74.5% in Kirklees. Both are comfortably above 50%, but the 18.8-percentage-point gap between them is not trivial. In four of the five West Yorkshire districts, cyclist submissions produced better outcomes than vehicle driver submissions — in Wakefield the gap was 20.9 percentage points in favour of cyclists, in Calderdale 19.4, in Bradford 16.6, in Leeds 15.4. Kirklees was the exception. It was the only district where vehicle driver submissions had a marginally higher positive outcome rate than cyclist submissions — 76.6% for drivers against 74.5% for cyclists. The difference is small — just 2.1 percentage points — but Kirklees is the only district where the relationship is inverted. Kirklees also recorded the highest cyclist NFA rate at 25.5% — one in four cyclist submissions resulted in no further action. The data cannot show whether that reflects the quality of the footage submitted or differences in how officers assess it.
Bradford recorded the highest cyclist positive outcome rate of any district at 90.4%, but nearly all of those outcomes were educational courses — 87.2%. Bradford’s conditional offer rate for cyclist submissions was just 3.2%. It recorded zero court prosecutions from cyclist submissions. Bradford produced outcomes, but those outcomes sat almost exclusively at the lowest tier of the disposal system.
A common claim on social media is that police do not take action against cyclists. Operation Snap was built around motor vehicles — registration plates, registered keepers, motoring offence codes. The entire system assumes the offender is driving a car, van, or lorry. It was not designed to deal with cyclists. But there is one route through which it can. If a cyclist submits footage that also captures their own riding, the police can review the full footage and act on what they see. The cyclist has identified themselves by submitting it. That is what happened in the Menston prosecution in 2026. In Q1 2023, 526 cyclists submitted footage through Operation Snap. The data show not a single case in which the system acted against a cyclist through their own submission — no record in which the reporter was a cyclist and the offender vehicle was a bicycle. The data do contain one bicycle. In February 2023, a vehicle driver in Wakefield submitted footage reporting a cyclist — recorded as make “BIKE”, model unknown, colour blue. The submission resulted in no further action. Bicycles do not carry registration numbers — cycling is a common law right and does not require vehicle registration — so the system had no way to identify the rider. A driver reporting a cyclist is a dead end. A cyclist incriminating themselves through their own footage is the one mechanism that works. In this quarter, across 526 cyclist submissions, it did not happen once.
The 79 pedestrian submissions tell a different story. The positive outcome rate was 40.5% — more than 40 percentage points below the cyclist figure. Of the 79 submissions, 47 resulted in no further action. In Bradford, nine of the 10 pedestrian submissions resulted in no further action. RT88966 — failing to comply with an endorsable traffic sign — appeared most frequently, accounting for 16 of the 32 pedestrian submissions in which the system identified an offence. The system found an actionable offence in fewer than half of all pedestrian submissions.
Horse riders submitted 58 reports. The positive outcome rate was 65.5%. The geographic pattern stands out — 24 of the 58 horse rider submissions came from Kirklees, more than double any other district. Leeds recorded 21. Bradford and Calderdale recorded just four each. Whether this reflects where horse riders encounter dangerous driving or where they are more aware of the scheme is an open question.
Total submission volumes grew across the quarter — 425 in January, 500 in February, 621 in March. Cyclist submissions were steadier at 169, 177, and 180. Vehicle driver submissions drove the growth, rising from 192 in January to 349 in March.
The Q1 2023 data establish several baseline patterns. The disposal system operates on a largely predictable hierarchy driven by offence code rather than case-by-case assessment of severity. RT88576 — which accounts for three quarters of cyclist submissions — produces educational courses in 98.5% of cases and court prosecutions in none. When officers charge the same driving behaviour under RT88575, it can result in conditional offers and court prosecutions. The data do not tell us how that charging decision is made. Cyclist submissions produce a positive outcome more often than submissions from any other reporter type, but educational courses account for the majority of those outcomes. The system was built to deal with drivers. In Q1 2023, that is what it did. Whether the type of action it produces is proportionate to the driving behaviour that cyclists report is a different question, and one that future quarters of data will help to answer.
Data source: West Yorkshire Police Operation Snap, January–March 2023. Analysis by West Yorkshire Cycling.


























